{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "Meeting Minutes\nCity of Oakland\nOffice of the City Clerk\nOakland City Hall\n1 Frank H. Ogawa Plaza\nOakland, California 94612\nLaTonda Simmons, City Clerk\n*Public Safety Committee\nOakland City Hall, 1 Frank H. Ogawa Plaza, Oakland, California, 94612\nCity of Oakland Website: http://www.oaklandnet.com\nTuesday, June 28, 2005\n7:30 PM\nCity Council Chambers - 3rd Floor\nThe Oakland City Council Public Safety Committee convened at 7:36 P.M.,\nwith Councilmember Reid presiding as Chairperson.\nRoll Call / Call to Order\nCouncilmember Present: 4 - Member Nadel, Member Kernighan, Member Quan\nand Chair Reid\nCOMMITTEE MEMBERSHIP:\n1\nApproval of the Draft Minutes from the Committee Meeting held on June 14, 2005\nA motion was made by Member Quan, seconded by Member Nadel, to\n*Approve the Minutes. The motion carried by the following vote:\nVotes:\nCouncilmember Aye: Member Nadel, Member Kernighan, Member Quan and\nChair Reid\n2\nDetermination of Schedule of Outstanding Committee Items\nA motion was made by Member Nadel, seconded by Member Kernighan, to", "page": 1, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "Approve as Amended. The motion carried by the following vote:\nVotes:\nCouncilmember Aye: Member Nadel, Member Kernighan, Member Quan and\nChair Reid\nFROM PENDING NO SPECIFIC DATE\nSubject: Emergency Management Board Proceedings\nFrom:\nOakland Fire Department\nRecommendation: Receive A Semi-annual Report On Emergency Management Board\nProceedings For The Period January 2005 - June 2005 (05-0594)\nScheduled to *Public Safety Committee on 9/13/2005\nSubject:\nSettlement Agreement Tasks\nFrom:\nOakland Police Department\nRecommendation: Receive A Status Report From The Chief Of Police Outlining The Oakland\nPolice Department's Efforts To Implement The Provisions Required In The Negotiated\nSettlement Agreement Of Delphine Allen, Et Al, v. City Of Oakland, Et Al, United States", "page": 2, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "District Court Case No. C00-4599 (TEH) (05-0572)\nScheduled to *Public Safety Committee on 7/12/2005\nView Report.pdf\n(PSC Item 2 6-28-05)\nView Item\n3\nSubject:\nSideshow Activities\nFrom:\nOakland City Council\nRecommendation: Action on A Report and Recommendations Regarding Two Alternatives To\nAddress Sideshow Activities: Alternative No. 1 - An Ordinance Amending Title 9 Of The\nOakland Municipal Code To Add Chapter 9.60 (a) Declaring Vehicle Sideshows A Public", "page": 3, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "Nuisance And (b) Prohibiting The Gathering Of Spectators At Such Public Nuisance Events;\nAnd Alternative No. 2 - An Ordinance That Includes The Foregoing Provisions And Also\nProvides For The Forfeiture Of Vehicles Involved In Sideshow Events (05-0429-1)\nA motion was made by Member Quan, seconded by Member Kernighan,\nthat this matter be *Approve as Amended the Recommendation of Staff,\nand Forward to the Special Concurrent Meeting of the Oakland\nRedevelopment Agency/City Council, due back on July 12, 2005. The\nmotion carried by the following vote:\nVotes:\nCouncilmember Abstained: Member Nadel\nCouncilmember Aye: Member Kernighan, Member Quan and Chair Reid", "page": 4, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "The Committee moved seconded and carried a motion to accept staff", "page": 5, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "recommendations as amended:", "page": 6, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "", "page": 7, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "This chapter is adopted to prohibit sideshow gatherings, processions and", "page": 8, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "assemblages on city streets and highways and to prohibit the gathering of", "page": 9, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "spectators at these events. The purpose of this law is to significantly curb this", "page": 10, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "illegal and nuisance activity. The law targets a very clear, limited population", "page": 11, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "and gives proper notice to citizens of the activities that are considered a", "page": 12, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "nuisance and prohibited under this ordinance. In prohibiting this activity and", "page": 13, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "discouraging spectators, the city intends to take a significant step toward", "page": 14, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "making its streets and highways safe to pedestrians, motorists and the general", "page": 15, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "public.", "page": 16, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "", "page": 17, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "Include the following language:", "page": 18, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "With this ordinance, the City Council seeks to achieve reform, education, and", "page": 19, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "reduce recidivism rates of persons involved in sideshow activity. To that end,", "page": 20, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "the City supports the administration and enforcement of this ordinance in a way", "page": 21, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "that emphasizes community service, education and training (including parental", "page": 22, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "participation for those violations committed by juveniles). To the extent that the", "page": 23, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "law permits these community-service alternatives to the criminal penalties", "page": 24, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "provided under this Ordinance, the City Council supports those alternatives.", "page": 25, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "", "page": 26, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "It is the expectation of the City Council that the City Administrator and the", "page": 27, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "Oakland Police Department work with the City Attorney's office, Alameda", "page": 28, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "County District Attorney's office, Alameda County Probation and Alameda", "page": 29, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "County Juvenile Court to identify specific community service and educational", "page": 30, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "alternatives for violations of the ordinance.", "page": 31, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "", "page": 32, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "SECTION 9.60.030 DEFINITIONS", "page": 33, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "\"Spectator\" means a person who is knowingly present at the location of a", "page": 34, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "sideshow and who is encouraging, facilitating or aiding and abetting in the", "page": 35, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "sideshow activity. To be present means a person who is within 100 feet of a", "page": 36, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "sideshow activity.", "page": 37, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "", "page": 38, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "Include the following language: Encouraging is defined as someone who urges", "page": 39, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "and assists participants through actions and/or words", "page": 40, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "", "page": 41, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "SECTION 9.60.70 RELEVANT CIRCUMSTANCES TO PROVE A VIOLATION", "page": 42, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": ".\nWhether the individual is facilitating the illegal activity in any manner, such", "page": 43, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "as by encouraging the event, obstructing foot or vehicular traffic or placing", "page": 44, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "barricades or other obstructions upon any highway.", "page": 45, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "Include: Encouraging is defined as someone who urges and assists participants", "page": 46, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "through actions and/or words", "page": 47, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "", "page": 48, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "SECTION 9.60.90 ENFORCEMENT - PENALTIES FOR VIOLATIONS", "page": 49, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "Violations of this Ordinance shall be as follows. The first offense shall", "page": 50, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "constitute an infraction punishable by a fine of not more than $500 and/or", "page": 51, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "community service and education. The second offense shall constitute an", "page": 52, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "infraction punishable by a fine of not more than $750 and/or community service", "page": 53, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "and education. The third and any subsequent offenses shall constitute a", "page": 54, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "misdemeanor punishable by a fine of $1,000, and/or community service and", "page": 55, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "education, by imprisonment not exceeding six months, or both. This provision", "page": 56, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "shall not be read to preclude the charging or imposition of any other penalties", "page": 57, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "authorized by law.", "page": 58, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "", "page": 59, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "We would like to direct the Oakland Police Department to return to the Public", "page": 60, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "Safety Committee in six months with a report updating the committee on their", "page": 61, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "training efforts, public awareness and education, and enforcement of this", "page": 62, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "ordinance. The committee further directs the Oakland Police Department to", "page": 63, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "come back to the council in one year with a report on the overall effectiveness", "page": 64, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "of the ordinance.", "page": 65, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "", "page": 66, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "The following individual(s) spoke in favor of this item:", "page": 67, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- Mark Daly", "page": 68, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- Jose' Dorado", "page": 69, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- Benjamin Scott", "page": 70, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- Jim Ensign", "page": 71, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- Stephanie Allen", "page": 72, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "suacw -", "page": 73, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- Nicholas Vigilante", "page": 74, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- Marcus Johnson", "page": 75, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "", "page": 76, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "", "page": 77, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "The following individual(s) spoke against this item:", "page": 78, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- Wendy Snyder", "page": 79, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- Matthew Willis", "page": 80, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- Aimee Allison", "page": 81, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- Sitara Nieves", "page": 82, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- Forrest Hill", "page": 83, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- Mary Van Der Horst", "page": 84, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- Venus Rodriguez", "page": 85, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- Michael Rubin", "page": 86, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- Janet Arnold", "page": 87, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- John Morton", "page": 88, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- Wilson Riles", "page": 89, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- Chris Cantor\n- Robert Rose", "page": 90, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- Bakari Olantunji\n- Gwen Hardy", "page": 91, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- Rashidah Grinage\n- Ora Knowell", "page": 92, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "", "page": 93, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "The following individual(s) spoke and did not indicate a position on this item:\n- Eugene Davis", "page": 94, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- Svea O'Banion\n- Jane Jackson", "page": 95, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- Linda Evans\n- Monique Jones", "page": 96, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- Renialdi Wilder\n- Felicia Moore-Jordan", "page": 97, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- Elder Freeman\n- Shirley Waters", "page": 98, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "- Jean Blackshear\n- Sanjiv Handa\nView Report.pdf,\nView Supplemental Report.pdf,\n12695 CMS.pdf\n4", "page": 99, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}
{"body": "PublicSafetyCommittee", "date": "2005-06-28", "text": "Subject:\nMotorized Scooters / Motorized \"Pocket Bikes\"\nFrom:\nOakland Police Department\nRecommendation: Approve The Introduction (First Reading) Of An Ordinance Adding Chapter\n10.17 To The Oakland Municipal Code Requiring Sellers Of Motorized Scooters And\nMotorized \"Pocket Bikes\" To Advise Consumers Of The State And Local Laws Regulating The\nOperation Of The Devices Within The City Of Oakland (05-0525)\nA motion was made by Member Nadel, seconded by Member Quan, that\nthis matter be *Approve the Recommendation of Staff, and Forward to the\nConcurrent Meeting of the Oakland Redevelopment Agency / City Council,\ndue back on July 19, 2005 as a Consent Calendar item. The motion carried", "page": 100, "path": "PublicSafetyCommittee/2005-06-28.pdf"}